Most significantly, these experiences helped me recognize that legitimacy is not simply an external organizational condition, but also an internal psychological experience. Repeated experiences of emotional reframing, social distancing, or subtle delegitimization can produce exhaustion, hypervigilance, and relational isolation, even when concerns are grounded in substantive organizational issues. Over time, I recognized that the emotional strain stemmed less from speaking critically and more from existing within institutional environments where legitimacy, professionalism, and belonging were unevenly distributed and continually negotiated. (Grab, “Legitimizing Power”, 2026)
I should have known there was an issue when I, myself, assigned and completed the County Ethics training that individuals are required to take upon appointment to a Board.
A little over a year ago, I was appointed to the County Behavioral Health Board. I dove in and immediately saw ways that I could contribute to my community. Prior to working as a civil servant, I led human resources in a locked psychiatric facility. I also happen to have personal experience with trauma and caregiving going back decades. I know all too well the toll that caregiving takes on anyone, especially those that caregive for work in addition to caregiving in their personal lives. I thought that by applying to the behavioral health board, I could get involved and potentially even have a positive impact on my colleagues’ lives. I interviewed with my District supervisor—I was hopeful, it was good interview. I expressed concerns I had about county leadership, about my hopes to improve the lives of the behavioral health workforce, and explained how I wanted to engage, etc. in the system. When I eventually received notice that I would be sworn in, I was proud. I was ready to expand my learning around inclusion, civic participation, representation, and community feedback. I resigned last month.
But let me tell you why…
It was my second board meeting. It took place in my District, at our community center. I was prepared—I read the previous meeting’s minutes and was excited to get to work. I arrived a little early and sat down next to another Board member from my district and we started chatting about our experiences—we were both fairly new. I was sitting at the front table, just left of the middle of the room at the pre-assigned Board member table when the county behavioral health director came in. I had seen them once, when I first started at my county job, at a labor-management meeting. They seemed engaged, sincere and generally like someone I would love to work with. I was impressed. I was not expecting what came next.
I smiled and was about to introduce myself, properly this time. I arrived late to the previous Board meeting—of course I did—it was my first meeting as a member, and per Murphy’s Law of First Impressions, I would be late. The director and I made eye contact and my smile was met with a pointed finger and a snarled lip. They uttered the phrase, “You do not belong here, you need to leave”, or some variation of that. They then walked over and sat down next to me and in what I found to be a terse and reproachful manner, stated that I was not welcome as a Board member because of a conflict of interest. I panicked—I had gone through the application, interview and selection process—I was confused. If this was true, how could I have been appointed? I thought they vetted applications for this role! I also did not understand what conflict they were referring to, I did not work for behavioral health or benefit financially from my appointment. I asked them what was prompting their reproachful manner and they stated that they were contacting my manager and my former colleague and repeated that I did not belong at the meeting and I needed to leave. They pulled out their phone.
Gobsmacked.
Several weeks before, I was asked for a favor by a former colleague who worked in Behavioral Health, to try out a training I developed for a separate department on their staff—a test run. I did that and the short version is that I stopped the training mid-presentation to address competing conversations, constant interruptions, and general disrespectful behavior. I believe in accountability and have a couple of decades of conflict resolution and mediation experience tucked under my belt, so I engaged the discomfort. I managed to turn the meeting around and into a Q&A with their managers, which is what they, as a group, were expecting—a surprise to me.
“Humiliations Galore”
I snapped out of my momentary stupor and asked them if their behavior toward me stemmed from my speaking up about my experience of disrespectful behavior while visiting their department. Their terse reply was that my appointment was a conflict of interest and they had just then messaged my manager and colleague so that I would be removed from the meeting. My vantage point was awful in that I was seated next to them and could see my colleague and manager’s names pop up as they texted responses—the display settings were adjusted to show text as larger than standard—the phone was on their lap and the screen lit up for every text. It was awful. At one point during this interaction, my fellow District board member asked me why they were trying to have me removed. I remember texting my husband in a state of disbelief. Oh god, more bullies. This, on top of what I was experiencing in the workplace. What the hell was going on? Why was I being talked about? Why were my manager and a former colleague involved? “Hi County, It’s Me Gaslighting” indeed.
By chance, the Board meeting started out discussing the orientation process and I stated my experience with my own ‘onboarding’, adding that the validity of my status was being questioned by the behavioral health director and I was not sure how to proceed. Someone gruffly stated that we could table it and it was never brought up again. I spent the better part of a year trying to convince myself that it was a misunderstanding. And, as I am wont to do, I assumed it was my fault (old programming, recently got an upgrade—I went Open-Source). I try to give people the benefit of the doubt, usually to my own detriment. Unfortunately, I’ve had the experience of being bullied throughout my life— it stings. I am always working on being brave, speaking honestly, holding myself and others accountable, emphasis on “working on”. I had hoped that in civil service, there would be other leaders like me. I’m still waiting. I never got an apology or an acknowledgement from the director, just a ‘request to speak’ by my manager the next day, code for how it was my fault. I wrote an email to the County Administrator’s office asking for accountability and respectful behavior from its staff, which I was assured I handled appropriately. Thanks? Of course I did, that’s not the issue. The issue is how they would hold the director accountable. They wouldn’t. The email was acknowledged. I stuck it out—this work is important to me. My job is important to me. I did what I was taught is appropriate and I pretended it never happened even though I was sick to my stomach every meeting following.
Earlier this year, I submitted a proposal to overhaul the site visit protocols to include updated surveys, data collection, standards, naming conventions and accountability, in addition to input from the workforce and community members with equal weight. At what would become my final meeting, a fellow Board member stated that I had not requested assistance in developing my proposal. I had. I have the emails documenting those requests. After months of pushing it forward we were finally voting on it. I found myself once again presenting, and once again noticing the good doctor walking out when it was my turn on the agenda. And for whatever reason, that member decided it was appropriate to complain on public record about something he chose not to participate in and gave me a verbal spanking. Everyone deserves to be treated with dignity and respect—if he couldn’t show it to me, I would do my best to show it to him. I did my best.
I asked if he would take over—I was happy to have someone else take the lead, I don’t need the extra work. The proposal passed. Something else had changed. I witnessed my last fuck fly away from the barren field that was once overrun by them. I refused to allow myself to be bullied. Period. No more. That decision prompted one link to break, in a chain of events that led to complete disengagement. This is not how boards work. This is not civil service. This is not social justice. This is not representative governance. This is crazy pants. I reached the point where I could say, “fuck around and find out” and back it up with 30 years of professional, academic and lived experience. To me, these experiences illustrate something deeply troubling about public institutions: conduct that undermines participation can go unaddressed, even when those institutions publicly champion inclusion, accountability, and representative governance. At some point, enough is enough. I called it. And now I understand the level of frustration that our community members feel—I think that was the most action they’d seen on a Board in years.
What does an institution communicate about civic participation when an appointed community representative can be challenged this way, publicly, by an official of the very department the board is supposed to advise?
What happens when a minoritized civil servant attempts to address inequity in the workplace?
I didn’t leave because I didn’t care enough to participate—after that public attempt to toss me a year ago, I doubled down, I engaged. I thought if I tried harder, it would get recognized <insert eye-roll of empathy here from every minoritized person, ever>. I left because participating required accepting treatment I would never tell another community member or member of the county workforce they should have to endure. How can a public agency extol virtues it does not embody and continue to do so with no accountability? Humanity has not been stripped from institutions. It was never there to begin with. These institutions are built on capitalism, and as its own creator, Mr. Adam Smith acknowledged in his oft ignored first work, Moral Sentiments, capitalism without empathy is like a plague of locusts. (I’m paraphrasing.) Let me introduce you to Reagan, Thatcher, a shitty economist not worthy of naming, and you have the advent of neoliberalism. You get the means, you keep the means by any means necessary. Fuck everyone and everything else, you have more money than 92% of the world’s population. Welcome to today.
This is the crux of my academic work. Just who counts when decisions are made? How much is swept under the rug in the name of business as usual (aka don’t mess with my ego, I won’t mess with your job.) Workplace bullying needs to be addressed across the board and bullies need to be held accountable for their actions, especially when they are the ones in power. Everything we ever needed to know, we learned in pre-school from our underpaid “surrogate-parent” teachers.
Appointment is not the same as participation. Participation is not the same as influence. And influence is not the same as institutional accountability.
Search it:
Adam Smith completely agreed with the idea that a market system devoid of ethics, empathy, and social care is destructive. While he is famously celebrated as the "father of capitalism" for his 1776 book The Wealth of Nations, popular culture often ignores his first major work, The Theory of Moral Sentiments(1759). In it, Smith argues that human society is entirely dependent on mutual empathy—what he called "sympathy" or "fellow-feeling." [1, 2, 3, 4]
Historians and economists often discuss this balance through a few key concepts:
1. "The Adam Smith Problem"
For decades, scholars debated an apparent contradiction in his work: Moral Sentiments claims humans are driven by a desire to care for others, while Wealth of Nations says free markets thrive on individual self-interest. Today, modern consensus clarifies that Smith never intended self-interest to mean cruel selfishness. Instead, he believed that a free market could only function safely if it was anchored by a strong, bottom-up moral framework where individuals naturally self-regulate out of care for their community. [1, 2, 3, 4]
2. Distortion of the "Invisible Hand"
Smith only used the phrase "invisible hand" a handful of times across his works. However, mid-20th-century economic movements—such as the Chicago School of Economics—isolated the phrase to argue that unbridled greed and hyper-individualism naturally produce the best outcomes. Scholars note that Smith would have rejected this, as he explicitly warned that unregulated monopolies and extreme inequality erode the social fabric. [1, 2, 3, 4]
3. Smith’s Warnings About Business Overreach
Smith was deeply suspicious of the political power of merchants and corporations. He openly wrote about:
The dangers of low wages: He argued that a society cannot flourish if the majority of its people are poor and miserable.
Sympathy with the powerful: He warned that humans have a dangerous tendency to admire the wealthy and disregard the poor, which can distort our moral judgment. [1, 2]
Ultimately, Smith viewed the economy as a tool to serve human well-being, not a system where human empathy should be sacrificed for the sake of GDP

